{
 "status": "accepted-as-control",
 "variant": "C",
 "ranking": "third; readyForFirstAudition false",
 "observations": [
  {
   "claim": "No chorus, refrain or returning hook",
   "disposition": "accepted-observation",
   "action": "By construction: C keeps the version-2 words verbatim to separate the music/arrangement effect from the text effect (plan §6, formPlan.controlWithoutHook). Its hookReturns row is expected to fail."
  },
  {
   "claim": "p18–p19 prose run, p48 aside, p52 padding",
   "disposition": "rejected-observation",
   "reason": "Changing these lines would change the control's words; the observations are recorded for the text comparison A/B vs C."
  }
 ],
 "at": "2026-09-17T07:19:09.323085+00:00",
 "review": "reviews/composition-v01 (Gemini 3.8 Flash, complete source in four audio parts + texts of A, B, C + version-2 text)",
 "panel": "preparation/panel: judge-A.md, refute-A-native.json, refute-A-advertorial.json (run 1); refute2-*-native/advertorial (run 2, final texts)"
}